Most already know that I feel most Uni IT courses are sadly out of date and out of tune with the real world of IT. As some have already said an IT degree in Twitter or Tweet-ing isn’t any good if we are going to be back on the top as world leaders in the IT race. Also it seems that most “Silver surfers” are getting a better course at the local U3A!
A lot of the Uni grads I get to work alongside with can “Tag”, “Poke” and play “Halo” like it’s an Olympic sport but can’t tell you a Network fault from a lost Video Driver! Why is that? Has the course failed them? Were they playing Halo instead of going to class? Or are we not telling the Colleges and Universities what we what to come out of the courses and from our graduates?
It’s bad enough for these would be IT Gurus but the latest news of the Universities “Charge what you like” course fees will put many out of the race to get any sort of real qualifications, not matter how out of date the courses are.
I really feel that the UK academic system is getting worse. The Asian countries beat us hands down not only in the quality of their courses but also the students and their dedication to learning. Many Asian students could teach here in the UK with what they already know and without the bonus of the certificate. OK, I know their standards are higher and if they don’t keep an 83% pass rate going they are “Sacked” from the course, but it really works to keep the standards up. Consider this thought, education is a gift not a right, that is what they say in Asia. This drives the student to achieve more, and they are glad to study and to achieve the best they can. The best students in Asia are not always the ones that can afford to pay the fees. They are the ones on scholarships and sponsorships because they have earned it and want it more than our students living off the “Bank of Mum and Dad.” The lecturers are better too, they are the best of the best and could easily command much higher salaries working for big world corporations.
So if the UK Universities and Colleges want to be considered “Businesses” and have the right to charge what they like, then the rating system we have for them is all wrong. They have to deliver more than what they have in the past and fit in with what is current and future thinking in the work place. It’s not about the pass rate, it is about what is being taught and it’s RELEVANCE in the real world. We, the employer, should grade the Universities, based on the intake of graduates abilities in the workplace. Most companies cannot afford to retrain those fresh out of Uni, and we shouldn’t have to. So why are the Universities and Colleges sending out IT Graduates with poor IT skills?
It shows the lecturers are not monitored or held accountable nearly enough. I want to see the lecturers graded like the students. As they say, “Those who can do, those who can’t teach”. Sadly that is so true of so many of the UK Lecturers today, and many can’t teach that well either! So like the students, if they fail their targets and objectives, they should be penalised for it or even sacked. If not the students are not getting anything for the higher fees and the standards go down yet again.
For all you would be students, it’s time for a real think about the Uni or college and the sort IT course you will take. Be aware, sadly many courses can only be deemed as “Blanket Courses”, they cover a little bit of everything but not enough to teach you anything long term useful. Great if you want to be a “Jack of all trades” and plan to learn “on the job” what you need. I know, “But you need that bit of paper to get your dream job” in the first place.
As a student you must…
1) Choose your College or Uni well, make sure it fits with what you want. Remember they are a business, if the product is shoddy, don’t buy it!
2) Check it is the right course for you. i.e. if you dream of being a programmer or a hardware engineer, check that this is the key element of the course, not just one small part of a bigger ”Blanket Course”.
3) Get a full syllabus of the course, and the timetable. (Ensure that all the lecturers have been employed to fill the course time, often they are not!).
4) Talk to those on the 2nd and 3rdyear of the course, get their views and find out what problems they have experienced. You will be surprised to hear what is wrong with the course. How many people bailed on the course ‘cos it was boring, not consistent, underfunded etc. You will be shocked as to how many have gone back to their old job because the course was a flop.
4a) What is the pass/fail rate for the course? And what were the grades?
5) Course fees are only a part of it. What is the local area like, housing cost, work chances (if any) and do a pretend shop, see what it’s going to cost you a week/month to live.
6) Plan your week, work, rest and play. Make sure you have time for all that and also get your assignments in on time.
7) If any of the above comes out badly, rethink your plans and go for the one that ticks ALL the boxes for YOU the student, THE CUSTOMER!
P.S Don’t live off the “Bank of Mum and Dad!” Do it all yourself.
As an employer we all should be talking to the Universities and Colleges to ensure they are teaching what we need to fill the future market place. I am on two panels for the Technical development of IT courses. Even with my extreme views of some Windows and Apple products (Evil Grin), the realisation of practical training based on real world experience has made courses more fitting to the employers needs.
Of course this is not a definitive list, and I hope others will add to this. Some of you out there already working in the world of IT may have sons or daughters who wish to follow in your footsteps. What would you tell them? Post it here too…
What would you want your new fresh out of Uni, IT guy to know when he starts work with you on Monday? Have you told the local Uni or College this?
Putting “being an IT Heretic aside”, computing is a fascinating world. It has done me well for over 30yrs, taking me all around the world, and I have seen somethings I can tell you (both good and bad). Both my sons have joined my company until their own passions took them off to other areas of IT. All I can say, with the course fees going up, and the salaries getting smaller, think long and hard about what you want out of your career, and what you are prepared to do to get the money. Sadly you can earn more aboard as a good Techie or Lecturer than you can here in the UK, but if you plan to have a wife and kids.. This may not fit in with your family life or the places you would like to work (some are very grim places, believe me very grim).
I have seen many IT firms go to the wall. So finally, as a student you can easily expect a 30-40k debt with these new fees, is it worth it? You could study to be a solicitor or an accountant instead and earn much, much more… Just a thought.
All the best












You know the situation: you arrive at the office on your first day back from holiday and your colleagues all ask you how your holiday was.





